Shopify vs WordPress: when a CNY business should open an online store
Key takeaways
- Shopify is the recommended platform for a CNY business whose website exists mainly to sell products; WordPress is the recommended platform for content and service-business sites.
- Shopify’s Basic plan lists $29 a month billed yearly or $39 billed monthly, with an online card rate of 2.9% plus 30 cents through Shopify Payments.
- Shopify charges a 2% transaction fee on its Basic plan when a store uses a third-party payment provider instead of Shopify Payments, dropping to 0.2% on Plus.
- Kinsta’s entry managed WordPress plan lists $315 a year on annual billing, before any store plugins, themes or payment processing fees.
- New York requires a Certificate of Authority for taxable sales, with registration at least 20 days before you begin business, whichever platform runs the store.
Last updated November 13, 2026.
Shopify vs WordPress comes down to what the website is for. If the site’s main job is taking orders, shipping products and tracking inventory, Shopify is the stronger choice for a CNY business; if the site’s main job is explaining services and publishing content, WordPress fits better. Shopify is a hosted e-commerce platform that runs your storefront, checkout and payments for a monthly fee, while WordPress is open-source website software you install on a host you choose.
The guide is for Central New York retailers, makers, farms, bakeries and specialty food producers in Onondaga, Oneida, Madison and the surrounding counties who are ready to sell online, and for service businesses wondering if they need a store at all. Prices come from Shopify’s, Kinsta’s and WordPress.org’s own pages as of November 2026, and tax rules from the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance.
When should a CNY business open an online store?
A CNY business should open an online store when it has products that ship or that customers want to buy ahead and pick up. A Utica bakery taking holiday cookie tray orders, a Cazenovia maple farm shipping syrup statewide, or a Syracuse gift shop selling SU-season merchandise can each move real sales online. A plumber or an accountant usually cannot, and a contact form does the job.
Timing also counts. Building a store in November for the December rush leaves little room to test checkout, shipping rates and tax settings. The Small Business Administration’s marketing and sales guide notes that a business selling online can accept payment through its website with an online payment service, and Shopify builds that service into every plan.
How much does Shopify cost compared with WordPress?
Shopify costs a fixed monthly plan fee plus a percentage of each card sale. WordPress costs hosting, plus whatever store plugin, theme and payment processor you add. The table below shows Shopify’s November 2026 plans from its pricing page:
| Shopify plan | Billed yearly | Billed monthly | Online card rate | In-person card rate | Third-party payment fee |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Basic | $29/mo | $39/mo | 2.9% + 30 cents | 2.6% + 10 cents | 2% |
| Grow | $79/mo | $105/mo | 2.7% + 30 cents | 2.5% + 10 cents | 1% |
| Advanced | $299/mo | $399/mo | 2.5% + 30 cents | 2.4% + 10 cents | 0.6% |
| Plus | From $2,300/mo | Not listed | 2.25% + 30 cents | 2.3% + 10 cents | 0.2% |
Shopify’s pricing page describes a 3-day free trial, then $1 a month for 3 months on most plans. Basic includes no additional staff accounts; Grow includes 5 and Advanced 15. The Basic, Grow and Advanced plans each allow 10 inventory locations.
A WordPress store starts from hosting. Kinsta’s entry managed plan, Single 35k, lists $315 a year on annual billing for one site with 35,000 monthly visits. Store software comes from the WordPress.org plugin directory, which lists over 79,000 free plugins, and a payment processor charges its own per-sale rate. Paid extensions for shipping, subscriptions or wholesale pricing add to the bill. The hosting choice is covered in the WordPress guide for CNY businesses.
Why is Shopify recommended for e-commerce stores?
Shopify is recommended for e-commerce stores because the store is the product. Checkout, payments, inventory, hosting, security updates and the point-of-sale system come from one company under one bill. A Cortland County farm with two employees does not have to patch plugins or test a checkout after every update.
In-person selling is the other reason. Shopify’s in-person card rate on Basic is 2.6% plus 10 cents, and Shopify sells POS Pro as an add-on at $89 a month per location on the Basic, Grow and Advanced plans. A maker who sells online all year and at the State Fair or a holiday market can run both from one inventory count. Event selling is covered in the guide to State Fair and SU game-day marketing.
When does WordPress beat Shopify?
WordPress beats Shopify when selling is a small part of a content-heavy site. A Skaneateles inn selling gift cards, a Rome brewery selling event tickets, or a Utica nonprofit taking donations needs pages, events and blog posts first and a checkout second. Adding a store plugin to WordPress is often simpler than rebuilding the whole site on Shopify.
WordPress also gives more ownership. The software is licensed under GPLv2 or later, so the site can move to any host, and no platform fee applies to each sale beyond what your payment processor charges. The trade-off is upkeep: a WordPress store means keeping the store plugin, theme and extensions current, and testing checkout after updates. Managed hosting such as Kinsta, with daily backups and one-click staging on all plans, reduces that work but does not remove it.
The cost of leaving each platform
Moving off either platform takes work. A Shopify store runs on Shopify’s servers, so leaving means exporting products, customers and orders and rebuilding the design elsewhere. A WordPress store can change hosts with its design intact, and Kinsta lists unlimited free migrations on all plans. Leaving WordPress for Shopify, though, is a full rebuild either way.
What rules apply to any CNY online store?
Several New York and federal rules apply to an online store on any platform:
- Sales tax: the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance registration page requires a Certificate of Authority for taxable sales in New York, registered through New York Business Express at least 20 days before you begin business. County rates are in the CNY sales tax guide.
- Accessibility: the U.S. Department of Justice’s web accessibility guidance says the ADA applies to businesses open to the public, and names missing alt text, poor color contrast, missing captions and mouse-only navigation as common barriers. Product photos without alt text are a frequent store problem.
- Data security: the New York Attorney General’s data breach page says the SHIELD Act strengthens New York’s data-security laws, and the office takes breach reports through an online form.
On either platform, the store owner sets tax collection, writes alt text and controls who has staff logins.
Next steps before you build a store
A CNY business choosing between Shopify and WordPress can work through these steps:
- Count your products and estimate monthly orders. A catalog of dozens of shippable items points to Shopify; a few gift cards or tickets on a content site point to WordPress.
- Price a year on each platform: the Shopify plan plus card fees on your expected sales, against Kinsta hosting plus plugins and processor fees.
- Register for a Certificate of Authority if you don’t hold one, at least 20 days before the first sale.
- Decide if you sell in person too, and price Shopify’s POS Pro add-on at $89 a month per location if you do.
- Ask the Small Business Development Center in Syracuse to review your plan and projected costs before you commit.
This guide is general information for business owners, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules, rates and deadlines change, so confirm them with the agency named or with an attorney or accountant before you act.
See a rule or figure that has changed? Send us a correction.
Run a place readers should know about?
Get listed in the directory. Plans start at $190 a year; nonprofits are free.