Mamma Maria New York Pizzeria

Craving authentic New York pizza in Marathon? Mamma Maria New York Pizzeria is built around the idea of bringing the streets of NYC to a small Cortland County village. It serves pizza by the slice and as whole pies, in a classic Italian style.

The Italian menu goes beyond pizza, with freshly baked pastries and sandwiches. Everything is made fresh, in-house, daily, so the dough, sauces and baked goods come from the kitchen rather than a box. Marathon sits along the Tioughnioga River.

What to Know

• Pizza is sold by the slice and as whole pies.
• Freshly baked pastries and sandwiches are also on the menu.
• Everything is made fresh, in-house, daily.
• Marathon is a village on the Tioughnioga River in Cortland County.
• Experience Cortland features the pizzeria.