Carmella’s Cafe

Carmella’s Cafe in New Hartford has been a Central New York favorite for more than four decades. The menu blends authentic Italian traditions with classic American favorites, so a table of mixed tastes can usually find a dish everyone likes, from Italian comfort food to American standards.

That kind of staying power usually means a loyal local following, and takeout makes it easy to bring the food home. New Hartford is the main dining and shopping hub of the Utica area, so Carmella’s fits right in.

What to Know

• It has been a Central New York favorite for more than four decades.
• The menu pairs Italian dishes with classic American favorites.
• Takeout is available for meals at home.
• Carmella’s Cafe is a member of the New Hartford Chamber of Commerce and the Greater Utica Chamber of Commerce.