Toggenburg Mountain in Fabius sold to Douglas Wheeler in AG antitrust deal, with 2027-28 reopening planned
Local business owner Douglas Wheeler bought Toggenburg Mountain, the closed ski area in the Town of Fabius in Onondaga County, on Friday, October 16, 2026, according to the New York Attorney General’s office and the NYSkiBlog directory, which places the hill in Fabius. The seller, Intermountain Management, owns Labrador Mountain and Song Mountain, and the sale closed that day under a settlement that ends the state’s antitrust case over the 2021 shutdown.
Wheeler plans to rebuild the ski area and reopen for the 2027-28 season, the attorney general’s office said. The deal sets up a third ski resort in the Syracuse market after about five years in which, as the attorney general’s office describes it, Intermountain was the only operator.
The Toggenburg sale at a glance
The main points of the settlement and sale, drawn from the attorney general’s October 16 announcement and coverage the same day by FingerLakes1, are these.
- Intermountain Management sold Toggenburg Mountain to Douglas Wheeler, and the sale closed on October 16, 2026.
- Intermountain pays the State of New York $30,000 under the settlement.
- For four years, Intermountain may not try to buy Toggenburg back or enforce the no-poach agreement it signed with the ski area’s former owners.
- Wheeler intends to rebuild Toggenburg and reopen it for skiing in the 2027-28 season.
Where Toggenburg sits
The ski area is at 1135 Toggenburg Road, just off State Route 80 and about a mile east of the Village of Fabius, according to the NYSkiBlog directory. Fabius is in the southeastern corner of Onondaga County, and the town’s eastern edge is the Madison County line. The hill was especially popular with families from Cazenovia and Manlius, Oswego County Business magazine wrote in a December 2023 feature.
Before it closed, Toggenburg ran five lifts, including two double chairs by the lodge and a triple chair serving the steepest terrain, with 760 feet of vertical drop on about 83 skiable acres, according to NYSkiBlog. The trade publication SnowSports News reported in 2025 that the area had operated continuously from 1953 until the 2021 closure.
How Toggenburg closed in 2021
In the summer of 2021, John and Christine Meier, who also own Greek Peak Mountain Resort in the Town of Virgil, sold Toggenburg to Intermountain Management, according to an August 2021 announcement from Intermountain’s SkiCNY.com. The Meiers said they wanted to put their resources into Greek Peak. Intermountain president Peter Harris shut Toggenburg down right away and told former customers that their Song and Labrador passes and lift tickets would be honored. “The decision to close Toggenburg isn’t one we took lightly or made easily,” Harris said in that release.
The closure hit racing programs hard. The Toggenburg Junior Association and the Syracuse University and Colgate University ski teams had trained and raced on the hill, The NewsHouse at Syracuse University reported in September 2021. Racers and coaches said they were left looking for space at Song and Labrador, which run their own race teams.
The state later laid out what came with the deal. Intermountain paid the sellers to agree not to compete within 30 miles for five years, and the agreement barred them from hiring Intermountain workers. Intermountain also announced it would add a deed restriction to keep any future owner from running Toggenburg as a ski resort, the attorney general’s office said.
The lawsuit and the 2025 ruling
Attorney General James sued Intermountain in October 2022. Her office argued that Intermountain bought its only competitor in order to close the hill and steer skiers to its other two mountains. The suit asked the court to order Intermountain to sell one of its resorts, cancel the noncompete, give up money gained from Toggenburg customers who moved to its hills and pay civil penalties. “Monopolies are not a game,” James said when the case was filed. In a separate deal announced on October 21, 2022, John Meier agreed to pay the state $195,000, the amount Intermountain had paid him for the noncompete, and to cooperate with the case. That deal released him from the noncompete and no-poach terms.
On March 10, 2025, the attorney general announced that Justice Robert E. Antonacci II had granted the state summary judgment. The judge found that the Toggenburg purchase was an illegal agreement to divide the market under New York antitrust law, and that the no-poach clause had no valid business reason and was meant to suppress competition. The release said Intermountain partners Peter Harris and Richard Sykes coordinated the plan. The court left the remedy for later proceedings. James said at the time that Intermountain “paid a premium price to destroy competition.”
Remedy hearings followed. The state pressed for a court-ordered sale to a buyer who would run a ski area, while Intermountain sought approval to sell to a buyer with no Syracuse-area operating history who proposed building housing on the land, according to the attorney general’s office. SnowSports News reported in August 2025 that the state was seeking a $4 million penalty and that the judge favored a quick sale to someone who would reopen the hill. The final settlement set the payment at $30,000.
Who is buying Toggenburg
The attorney general’s office described Douglas Wheeler as a local business owner. NYSkiBlog reported in October 2026 that the Wheeler family of Fabius had announced the purchase and an intention to reopen the hill.
SnowSports News reported in August 2025 that Wheeler, a Fabius resident, had his first job at Toggenburg and that his great-grandfather once owned the property. That report said he had offered $1.75 million, below the $1.995 million asking price, and planned to move his sign-making and auto repair businesses to the site. The attorney general’s October 2026 announcement did not mention those business plans.
What the reopening plan includes
Details are thin so far. According to the October 2026 sources, the plan covers the following.
- Wheeler plans to rebuild Toggenburg before opening, with the 2027-28 ski season as the target, according to the attorney general’s office.
- Wheeler’s attorney, John Petosa, told SnowSports News in August 2025 that a reopening would need at least $2 million and several months of work.
- Some lifts might have to be reinstalled because equipment was reportedly removed after the closure, according to the same report.
- No figures for the investment, lift work, lodge work or hiring have been made public.
Zoning is another step. In December 2023, Fabius code enforcement officer Mike Decker told Oswego County Business that the land is zoned agricultural and that the ski center’s zoning variance lapsed after the business had been closed for more than a year.
“I am thrilled that New Yorkers will once again have access to Toggenburg Mountain,” James said in the October 16 announcement.
Other ski areas near Fabius
Toggenburg, Song Mountain in Tully and Labrador Mountain in Truxton sit within roughly 12 miles of one another, according to Intermountain’s 2021 announcement. Song and Labrador stay under Intermountain ownership. Greek Peak in Virgil, Cortland County, is less than half an hour away, Oswego County Business wrote. Closer to Syracuse, smaller hills include Four Seasons Golf and Ski Center in Fayetteville, along with the Cazenovia Ski Club and the Camillus Ski Hill.
For now, the Toggenburg site remains closed to the public. Wheeler has not announced dates for lift tickets, season passes or a reopening event.
Have a tip or a correction? Send it to CNY Magazine.
Have local news you'd like to share?
Openings, closings, milestones, events — send us the scoop and our editors will take a look.